Thursday, November 19, 2026

Christians a global minority by 2035

 That's the Religious News Service story, reporting on the latest Pew Research findings. Globally, if current birthrates continue, Muslims will pass Christians as the world's largest religion by 2035.

Fast forward another 30 years.

Christians are projected to fall below 50 percent of the US population in 2065. I think that's about the same time that the US will likely be majority non-White. 

Speaking of? Fast forward another 5 years.

Pew says that by 2070, the majority of global Christianity will be in sub-Saharan Africa. This will have ongoing implications for Catholicism and even more — where it already has — for the Anglican Communion. 

"Nones" are likely to continue to grow slightly in absolute numbers, but because of their likelihood to have even lower birth rates than Christians, to continue to flatline in terms of global population percentage. 

In the religious right of Protestants in the United States, these facts will post zero reflection, other than possibly additional doublings down on Islamophobia, new expansions of Hinduphobia, and new hatings on non-White immigrants. (African Americans as well as White Americans have a birthrate at or below replacement level.)

But, they should post lots of reflection. 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Goodbye, Marquise

 Marquise is the pseudonym, or book-reviewing nom de plume, of someone I came across on Goodreads what, about four years ago? Her reading, and reviewing, focus was on folklore and modern fantasy based on folklore, and since I had met her, had tightened more and more to retellings of Beauty and the Beast-type tales. She's "into" this enough, in a semi-academic sense even if not an academic sense, to have talked with me and others not only about the Stith Thompson, author of the Motif-Index of Folk-Literature, but also the Aarne-Thompson-Uther Tale Type Index, which focuses specifically on indexing such stories by type. Aarne was a Finn who started it. Thompson is the same Thompson, who built on it and expanded it 20-plus years later, and Uther is a German who did further expansion and organization early this century.

Here's what I said on her Goodreads announcement:

On the big picture? I guess there's not as much tribalism, and other things, in the world of nonfiction, eh? To the degree there is, like American political wingnuts? I call them out on their stupid reviews and then block them. As far as GR? Yes, the elimination of direct messages and other things has degraded it in some ways. On the other hand, it's now given us the fractional stars on reviews, so I am again happier. Maybe it will adapt other things from a site like Storygraph, like buttons up front to rank reading speed and ease.

And I mean that. She's from Europe, and though I don't believe she's ever said it specifically, everything I read says the Land of Eire.

Like many Irish, and for degrees of parallelism in history, she's strongly anti-Zionist, one definite point of agreement. 

That said, maybe I've read that incorrectly. One of the comments on a post on the website she created to focus on these retellings, and where, already more than a year ago, she had told me and others that she had broader long-term goals in mind, one commenter talks about losing "a fellow Slavic sister." OTOH, she's talked about wanting a church wedding and losing the originally planned piece, and other things that scream Catholic, and the majority of non-Protestant Slavs are of course Orthodox. 

Speaking of? Once, in some general update, she made some vague reference to being a refugee. When I asked more, she said it was in a long-ago update. And, Goodreads simply doesn't provide a link to every status update a person makes. Was it from the Troubles? Something else?

I don't mean this to be nosy, but, I would like to know her as a person. And, not to say that some tragedies are worse than others, beginning with the fact that, outside of economics, tragedies are generally qualitative not quantitative, but I would have liked part of that to be more discussion of relative tragedies.

And, part of that would also be wanting to learn more about what drives the Beauty and the Beast interest. 

You have my email, Marquise, should you ever read this. 

I probably won't "pursue." And, given your GR response on your update, I probably won't "see" you a lot more. 

Thursday, November 05, 2026

Defending neo-Stoicism against barbarian classicists

 Massimo Pigliucci recently came across Mary Beard and Emily Wilson, and got a burr in his saddle about both of them and their takes Stoicism and neo-Stoicism.

Here's Beard.

My thought? 

Without linking, if you object to Stoicism being called “fascist” as anachronistic as well as a wrongful description, do you also object to Platonism, at least “The Republic,” being called that? On “The Republic,” it’s at least 50 percent right.

(Massimo does mach that objection, on "presentism" grounds. I've already stated my disagreement on that.) 

==

As for fatalism? Well, of course it is. Any hardcore determinist philosophy is fatalistic in the denotative sense of the word. But, if you’re a determinist of sorts becoming more hardcore, you may not like that, and definitely may not like the hints of a connotative sense.

==  

As for Marcus Aurelius the conquerer? Well, if you want to argue with Mary Beard on how bad he was, fire away. "Not as bad as Caesar" is a weak defense. On the other hand, DO fire away; it wouldn't be the first time Beard overstated such claims.

Marcus displaced populations of Germanic peoples after wars across the borders, and within the empire, signed off on, and by imperial rescript, instigated a moderate-sized, persecution of Christians in Lyon. Previous emperors would surely have done the same, and that link says that Marcus even admired their Stoic-like Stoicism. But, "doing no worse" rather than doing better? On the third hand, martyrdom in 170s CE Gaul may not have happened, or at a minimum, not been as severe as claimed, per Candida Moss. And, it's not just Moss. Many modern scholars consider the story of Blandina to be third-century, not late-second, and of dubious authenticity.

======

Wilson? Pigliucci's plaint against her starts with presentism, as she notes that Epictetus never became an abolitionist. Well, part of my plaint against Pigliucci, a decade and more ago, was with his plaint against presentism, a plaint that has grown slowly but steadily, like Elijah's cloud on the horizon.

He goes on to say a presentist stance against not condemning slavery in the past is not "useful." I take that as meaning ethically useful. Nice to see a virtue ethicist dipping their toes into utilitarianism. 

==

The back-issue, of course, is Pigliucci's criticism (not critique) of presentism.